Why does frederic fall in love with catherine

He tells the Count that what he values most is someone he loves and that he "might become very devout," elaborating that his religious feeling comes at night. Like Catherine, Henry has made a religion of their love. For that matter, he has replaced his loyalty to the Italian army with loyalty to Catherine. In Switzerland, Catherine suggests she and Henry wear their hair the same length, so as to be more alike.

We're the same one. At last Frederic Henry has drawn abreast of Catherine Barkley with respect to wisdom about the world. How has he done so? By participating in love and war, and by making the hard choices that both demand. When he walks out of the hospital at novel's end, Lieutenant Frederic Henry is a different man than he was at the opening of A Farewell to Arms. He has caught up to Catherine Barkley and now understands the world and his place in it. Sadly, he carries that understanding into the rain alone and broken, and forever without her.

Previous Chapter XLI. Next Catherine Barkley. Removing book from your Reading List will also remove any bookmarked pages associated with this title. Are you sure you want to remove bookConfirmation and any corresponding bookmarks? My Preferences My Reading List. A Farewell to Arms Ernest Hemingway. She's simply less dynamic. The writer's use of Catherine to contrast dramatically with Henry — to show us just how much learning and growing he has yet to do — begins in the first scene they share together.

Henry is still playing childish games: telling her he loves her when he doesn't, for instance. Soon, however, the tables are turned. Catherine not only resists Henry's advances; she reveals that she knows he has been playing a game. Apparently she has been playing one too: "You don't have to pretend you love me," she tells Henry. Indeed, the latter may be attracted to Catherine precisely because of her aura of hard-earned maturity. Well, that and her hair. Catherine rejects organized faith, and yet unlike the priest-baiting officers at the front she is no nihilist.

She lives by a definite, unshakeable value system, and what she values is love. During one of the many nights they spend together in Milan, the couple discusses marriage, which Henry wants but Catherine resists for practical reasons. It would necessitate their separation, she explains — more worldly than he, despite his battlefield experience.

She reminds him and us of her having been formally engaged to the soldier who died. Then Catherine tells Henry that she has no religion. Thus, she feels happy with large painful contractions, believing they get her closer to her goal. At the same time, she feels disappointed in herself when her body does not comply with her plan and labor pains seem to weaken and fade.

Either way, she states that Frederic need not concern himself. Catherine accepts that she is dying. Her lack of religious belief is genuine, so she fears no afterlife.

But she feels angry at what she will miss out on. With her last words she tries to comfort Frederic and gives permission for him to move on. She is the only person in the room dealing with her death realistically.

Both Frederic and the doctor linger in denial, but Catherine shows herself to be practical to the end. SparkTeach Teacher's Handbook. Themes Motifs Symbols. Quotes Catherine Barkley Quotes. I was going to cut it all off when he died. I wanted to do something for him. He could have had anything he wanted if I would have known. I would have married him or anything, I know all about it now. I thought it would be worse for him. We are married privately.

You see, darling, it would mean everything to me if I had any religion. Those last four boys were awful. We leaned on the fence and watched the horses go by.